In Loving Memory of Carter Cunniff Death & Obituary : The Paul VI High School community in Haddonfield, New Jersey, is mourning the tragic and untimely loss of 17-year-old senior Carter Cunniff, whose life was cut short in a devastating car accident on April 15, 2025. A cherished son, student, athlete, and friend, Carter’s passing has left a profound void in the hearts of all who knew him.
A Tragic Accident
In the early hours of April 15, around 12:11 a.m., Carter was driving his Toyota Camry southbound on State Route 55 when his vehicle veered off the road, striking a concrete overpass support and a tree. New Jersey State Police responded swiftly, but Carter had already succumbed to his injuries at the scene. The cause of the accident is still under investigation. The sudden nature of the tragedy has left the community grappling with disbelief and sorrow.
A Bright Light in the Paul VI Community
To everyone who had the privilege of knowing him, Carter was much more than a student. He was a radiant presence—uplifting, kind, and driven. Whether on the field, in the classroom, or among friends, Carter carried himself with purpose, positivity, and unwavering dedication. His smile and spirit were contagious, and his leadership inspired those around him.
An Outstanding Athlete and Team Player
Volleyball
As a libero on the Paul VI Boys Volleyball Team, Carter made a lasting impression with his sharp instincts and relentless defense. In just two matches during the 2024-2025 season, he tallied an impressive 22 digs (an average of 11 per match), one kill, and four service aces. His standout performance against Camden Eastside, where he recorded nine digs and three aces, showcased his determination and leadership on the court.
Soccer
Carter also brought passion and skill to the Paul VI Boys Soccer Team. Known for his energy, dedication, and team-first mindset, he was a respected and valued player. His presence in the locker room lifted spirits, and his selfless approach to the game earned the admiration of both teammates and coaches.
A Cherished Friend and Role Model
Beyond athletics, Carter’s personality shone brightly. He was known for his infectious laughter, loyalty, and his ability to make others feel seen and appreciated. Always ready to lend a hand, he was a true friend who built relationships on respect and kindness. In the classroom, Carter was a curious and committed student who embodied the values of Paul VI High School—faith, excellence, leadership, and compassion.
A School and Community United in Grief
In a heartfelt statement, Paul VI High School expressed deep sorrow over Carter’s passing, saying:
“Carter Cunniff exemplified the very best of our school community—faith, excellence, leadership, and compassion. His loss is deeply felt by students, faculty, coaches, and families. We are united in grief and prayer, and we extend our deepest sympathy to Carter’s family and loved ones during this incredibly difficult time.”
Carter: A Legacy of Love
Carter is survived by his loving parents, Mike Cunniff and Diane Zalewski Cunniff. Mike, a logistics director at Holt Logistics and a graduate of Pennsylvania State University, was an ever-present supporter of his sons’ lives. Diane, though more private, has been a steadfast and nurturing presence. The Cunniff family is heartbroken, but they are deeply touched by the outpouring of love and support from friends, the school community, and beyond.
Plans are underway for a memorial service at Paul VI High School, where students, faculty, family, and friends will gather to honor Carter’s life and legacy. Details will be announced in the coming days. In addition, a GoFundMe campaign has been established to assist the family with funeral expenses and offer support during this difficult time.
Conclusion: A Life That Will Never Be Forgotten
Though Carter’s life ended far too soon, his impact will endure. He leaves behind a legacy of kindness, leadership, and joy that will continue to inspire all who knew him. His memory will forever live in the hearts of his family, friends, teammates, and the entire Paul VI High School community.
Rest in peace, Carter. Your light continues to shine in the lives you touched. You will never be forgotten.
